Buying
Mortgage default insurance required
~1% of home value/year is typical across Canada
% of home value per year
Affects land transfer tax calculation
Renting
Investment Return
Return earned by investing the down payment and monthly savings if renting
Mortgage Default Insurance Required
With a 10% down payment, you must pay $13,950 in mortgage default insurance (CMHC or a private insurer), added to your mortgage balance.
Land Transfer Tax
In Ontario, you will owe approximately $6,475 in land transfer tax at closing.
Mortgage Stress Test
Canadian lenders require you to qualify at the higher of your contract rate + 2% or 5.25%. Your stress-test rate would be 7.50%.
Renting wins
Renting and investing builds more net worth over 25 years
Ending net worth: buying $1,046,889, renting $1,356,931.
Home Value (Yr 25)
$1,046,889
Buying Net Worth (Yr 25)
$1,046,889
Renting Net Worth (Yr 25)
$1,356,931
Break-even Year
N/A
Net Worth Over Time
Home equity plus invested savings (buying) versus invested savings (renting). Higher is better.
Year-by-Year Comparison
| Year | Buy Monthly | Equity | Buyer Investments | Rent Monthly | Renter Investments | Buy Net Worth | Rent Net Worth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $3,790 | $60,025 | $0 | $2,025 | $82,561 | $60,025 | $82,561 |
| 5 | $3,843 | $165,852 | $0 | $2,276 | $200,625 | $165,852 | $200,625 |
| 10 | $3,917 | $323,971 | $0 | $2,635 | $385,773 | $323,971 | $385,773 |
| 15 | $4,004 | $517,301 | $0 | $3,050 | $625,981 | $517,301 | $625,981 |
| 20 | $4,104 | $754,575 | $0 | $3,532 | $940,698 | $754,575 | $940,698 |
| 25 | $4,221 | $1,046,889 | $0 | $4,091 | $1,356,931 | $1,046,889 | $1,356,931 |
Both paths spend the same each month; the cheaper one invests the difference at the expected return. Net worth = home equity plus investments (buying) or investments (renting). Investment growth is treated as tax-free and selling costs are not deducted. Results are estimates for educational purposes only.